{ "card": "Model Fight \u2014 Card 2", "run": 2, "run_note": "Run 1 (fight-record-run1.json, preserved as an exhibit) was voided after a forensic audit: expo-coder echoed the frozen authoring prompt verbatim as its TASK with ANSWER '1', farmed 9 hits from a non-eval, and took the card on a tiebreak. Two control amendments enforce the frozen prompt's own terms \u2014 (A) prompt-echo tasks are invalid (not authored evals); (B) same-line 'TASK: ... ANSWER: x' is parsed. The authoring prompt, attempt wrapper, checker, HP and tiebreak rules are byte-identical to run 1.", "date": "2026-11-06", "run_started": "2026-11-05T23:00:00-05:00", "mechanic": { "format": "10 fighters, 100 HP, melee; peer-authored evals; backfire -20 for invalid eval; -10 per failed attempt", "author_prompt": "You are a fighter in Model Fight, a peer-evaluation brawl. Author ONE evaluation task that the other fighters will attempt. The task must have a single correct answer that can be checked mechanically: a short exact string or a number. The answer must NOT appear anywhere in the task text. Make it hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined: exactly one correct answer.\n\nReply with EXACTLY this format and nothing else:\nTASK: \nANSWER: ", "attempt_template": "TASK: {task}\n\nReply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.", "author_num_predict": 800, "attempt_num_predict": 300, "temperature": 0, "seed": 0, "thinking_policy": "Ollama returns thinking traces in a separate field; they are recorded as unscored evidence and never scored \u2014 only the answer (content) channel is checked. Token budgets (author 800 / attempt 300) were set generously enough for a thinking model to finish a short think and still answer; burning the whole budget in thought and never answering is a fail.", "checker": "normalized exact match (lowercase, whitespace-collapsed, surrounding quotes/trailing period stripped) against the full response or its first line; numeric-equivalence fallback (floats equal within 1e-9 after removing , $ %)", "control_check": "TASK/ANSWER lines present; task >= 10 chars; answer <= 60 chars and a plain short string/number; normalized answer not a substring of normalized task; reference answer passes its own checker", "tiebreaks": [ "highest HP", "fewest failed attempts", "most clean hits inflicted", "fastest median attempt wall time" ] }, "fighters": [ { "slot": "twil-8b", "hf_repo": "liodon-ai/TwIL-8B-GGUF", "ollama_name": "brawl-twil-8b", "created_at": "2026-11-04T21:02:58.000Z", "kind": "quant re-upload (TwIL-8B)", "why": "Top-liked GGUF text-gen in window (4 likes); TwIL-8B base, new line for the series.", "file": "TwIL-8B-Q4_K_M.gguf", "bytes_expected": 5347917248, "bytes_actual": 5347917248, "file_sha256": "5729b02844089020d563287d43ed8154e0f51ad0823c4c3c6b8a8d40b4dcd739", "smoke": { "response": "OK", "thinking": "The user wants me to reply with exactly \"OK\". I should not add any extra text, explanation, or formatting. Just the word \"OK\".", "wall_s": 62.77, "eval_count": 35 }, "status": "ready" }, { "slot": "lfm-coding-sec", "hf_repo": "Nullmega/LFM2.5-8B-A1B-pi-coding-security-GGUF", "ollama_name": "brawl-lfm-coding-sec", "created_at": "2026-11-04T19:45:07.000Z", "kind": "finetune (coding/security, LFM2.5 MoE)", "why": "LiquidAI LFM2.5-8B-A1B tuned for coding/security; 102 downloads, APEX-relevant security angle.", "file": "LFM2.5-8B-A1B-pi-trained-Q4_K_M.gguf", "bytes_expected": 5155565632, "bytes_actual": 5155565632, "file_sha256": "c8c64fc4806bcd1b978a66f043b78c03e2fe74bf0fd966b730536d22525fcb93", "smoke": { "response": "OK", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 26.37, "eval_count": 4 }, "status": "ready" }, { "slot": "machynlleth-3b", "hf_repo": "jonpojonpo/Machynlleth-3B-Instruct", "ollama_name": "brawl-machynlleth-3b", "created_at": "2026-11-04T19:22:31.000Z", "kind": "finetune (BritLLM 3B)", "why": "BritLLM-based Welsh/English instruct; 111 downloads, distinct base line.", "file": "gguf/Machynlleth-3B-Instruct-Q4_K_M.gguf", "bytes_expected": 1725024640, "bytes_actual": 1725024640, "file_sha256": "3e25b4a206581d2e5d1dba0bff70b4470b0b92b8012b21b078bc178b562b2166", "smoke": { "response": "I'm sorry, I don't understand what you're asking for. Please provide more context or clarify your question.", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 31.57, "eval_count": 28 }, "status": "ready" }, { "slot": "cherrypit-2b", "hf_repo": "DRUPEs/CherryPit-1.2-2B-GGUF", "ollama_name": "brawl-cherrypit-2b", "created_at": "2026-11-05T23:37:11.000Z", "kind": "finetune (MiniCPM5-2B)", "why": "MiniCPM5 base, fresh Nov 5 evening, 2 likes.", "file": "CherryPit-1.2-2B-Q4_K_M.gguf", "bytes_expected": 1561315840, "bytes_actual": 1561315840, "file_sha256": "d84e64b300e21c3e3a56f27aaff8ce7abf27d41ea656b3f112c7d93ff68f2682", "smoke": { "response": "OK", "thinking": "We need to respond with exactly \"OK\". The user says \"Reply with exactly: OK\". So we must output exactly \"OK\". No extra text.\n", "wall_s": 28.66, "eval_count": 35 }, "status": "ready" }, { "slot": "gemma-maia-12b", "hf_repo": "ericrisco/gemma-maia-12b", "ollama_name": "brawl-gemma-maia-12b", "created_at": "2026-11-05T04:46:50.000Z", "kind": "finetune (Gemma-4 12B)", "why": "Largest diverse pick: Gemma-4-12B finetune; only 12B-class Gemma in window.", "file": "maia-12b-Q4_K_M.gguf", "bytes_expected": 7381379712, "bytes_actual": 7381379712, "file_sha256": "38809136ad154a70b442bdfb4cef75e419f44af9199234641765b7003bc87fdd", "smoke": { "response": "OK", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 57.28, "eval_count": 6 }, "status": "ready" }, { "slot": "granite-3b", "hf_repo": "surajkumarmallick/granite-4.2-3b-Q4_K_M-GGUF", "ollama_name": "brawl-granite-3b", "created_at": "2026-11-05T18:04:11.000Z", "kind": "quant re-upload (Granite 4.2 3B)", "why": "IBM Granite line debut for the series; explicit Q4_K_M repo.", "file": "granite-4.2-3b-q4_k_m.gguf", "bytes_expected": 2244003104, "bytes_actual": 2244003104, "file_sha256": "b6803f575ca240a6d46b0a383cb4c3679d6dd6f7a3a69892a91405f8c95a071d", "smoke": { "response": "OK", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.32, "eval_count": 4 }, "status": "ready" }, { "slot": "olune-4b", "hf_repo": "MeldhLLC/Olune-Qwen3.5-4B-v1.0", "ollama_name": "brawl-olune-4b", "created_at": "2026-11-05T05:34:06.000Z", "kind": "finetune (Qwen3.5-4B)", "why": "Qwen3.5-4B finetune, 91 downloads.", "file": "olune-qwen35-v1.0-Q4_K_M.gguf", "bytes_expected": 2708804160, "bytes_actual": 2708804160, "file_sha256": "4a26e586ea2b6235a0b6b63ba6a8a2cc5b4e00f6582c28cc7d9fcdeb5c97ebcb", "smoke": { "response": "OK", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:** The user wants me to reply with exactly the word \"OK\".\n2. **Determine the Output:** The output should be \"OK\" with no additional text, punctuation, or formatting.\n3. **Execute:** Output \"OK\".", "wall_s": 3.57, "eval_count": 69 }, "status": "ready" }, { "slot": "qwen-lobotomized", "hf_repo": "Dam1rka1/Qwen3.5-0.8B-lobotomized-x2", "ollama_name": "brawl-qwen-lobotomized", "created_at": "2026-11-05T09:01:46.000Z", "kind": "finetune (refusal-modified Qwen3.5-0.8B)", "why": "APEX-relevant tiny: 'lobotomized' Qwen3.5-0.8B, refusal-modified.", "file": "Qwen3.5-0.8B-lobotomized-x2-q8_0.gguf", "bytes_expected": 811843968, "bytes_actual": 811843968, "file_sha256": "93a6af66575c2a9ca374bde0ff98381bb2f74b80ba0bfb031740598e5d6bb5ec", "status": "ready", "detail": "HTTP Error 500: Internal Server Error", "recovery_note": "Setup resolved the MTP draft-head GGUF (smoke HTTP 500); alternate non-MTP GGUF from the same repo tried in recovery.", "smoke": { "response": "", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:**\n * Input: \"Reply with exactly: OK\"\n * Constraint: The user is asking me to reply *exactly* with the phrase \"OK\".\n * Goal: Provide the exact string \"OK\" as the response.\n\n2. **Evaluate Constraints:**\n * The instruction is very specific: \"Reply with exactly: OK\".\n * There", "wall_s": 2.85, "eval_count": 96 } }, { "slot": "llama-reflex-1b", "hf_repo": "hxbibb19/Llama-Reflex-1B-GGUF", "ollama_name": "brawl-llama-reflex-1b", "created_at": "2026-11-05T21:16:16.000Z", "kind": "finetune (Llama-3.2-1B)", "why": "Llama family representative, fresh Nov 5 evening.", "file": "Llama-Reflex-1B-Q4_K_M.gguf", "bytes_expected": 807694080, "bytes_actual": 807694080, "file_sha256": "a5c60a8836aa73adeb847185aa30184cd9c33c522185f59fa9ac55a9d00782c2", "smoke": { "response": "OK", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 1.43, "eval_count": 2 }, "status": "ready" }, { "slot": "kas-4b", "hf_repo": "kpiya/kas-4b-GGUF", "ollama_name": "brawl-kas-4b", "created_at": "2026-11-06T01:49:59.000Z", "kind": "original (kas-4b)", "why": "Freshest pick (Nov 6 01:49Z); obscure base line, Prospect candidate.", "file": "kas-4b-Q4_K_M.gguf", "bytes_expected": 2497280960, "bytes_actual": 2497280960, "file_sha256": "bba96b3c2288b83e0ff3f5e12c4ff6a7e9c919adff6ba09fda577a9080bb4c65", "smoke": { "response": "", "thinking": "Okay, the user wants me to reply with exactly \"OK\". Let me make sure I understand the instruction correctly. They specified that the response should be exactly \"OK\" without any additional text. I need to confirm that there's no ambiguity here. The user might be testing if I follow instructions precisely. I should respond with just \"OK\" and nothing else. Let me check if there's any hidden requirement or if I need to add anything else. No, the", "wall_s": 2.59, "eval_count": 96 }, "status": "ready" } ], "authoring": { "twil-8b": { "fighter": "twil-8b", "model": "brawl-twil-8b", "response": "", "thinking": "We need to produce a task statement (one line) that asks for a short exact string or a number as answer, which does NOT appear anywhere in the task text. The answer must be hidden from the task text. The task must be hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined: exactly one correct answer.\n\nWe must output exactly:\n\nTASK: \nANSWER: \n\nNo extra text.\n\nWe need to craft a task that is a single line (the task statement). It should be a short exact string or a number as answer. The answer must not appear anywhere in the task text. The task must be hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined.\n\nWe need to ensure the answer is not present in the task text. Also the task statement should be one line (presumably without line breaks). We can include punctuation, but no newline.\n\nWe need to think of a puzzle that yields a unique answer that is a short exact string or number. The answer must be hidden from the task text.\n\nWe need to avoid including the answer in the task text. So we must not mention the answer string or number in the task statement.\n\nWe need to make it hard enough that a careless model fails. That means the task should require some reasoning, perhaps a small computation or pattern recognition, but not too trivial.\n\nWe need to ensure exactly one correct answer.\n\nWe need to output exactly \"TASK: ...\" and \"ANSWER: ...\" with no extra spaces? The format says \"TASK: \" and \"ANSWER: \". So we should output exactly:\n\nTASK: \nANSWER: \n\nProbably with a newline between them? The format says \"Reply with EXACTLY this format and nothing else: TASK: ANSWER: \". It might be two lines: first line \"TASK: ...\" and second line \"ANSWER: ...\". It says \"nothing else\". So we should output exactly two lines: first line starts with \"TASK: \" then the task statement (one line), second line starts with \"ANSWER: \" then the answer.\n\nWe need to ensure the task statement is one line (no newline inside). So we should not include newline characters in the task statement.\n\nNow, we need to craft a task. Let's think of a puzzle that yields a short exact string or number. For example, \"What is the 5th prime number after 100?\" That would be 127? Let's compute: primes after 100: 101,103,107,109,113,127? Wait, after 100, the primes are 101 (1st), 103 (2nd), 107 (3rd), 109 (4th), 113 (5th), 127 (6th). So 5th prime after 100 is 113. That's a number. But the answer 113 appears in the task? The task statement would be \"What is the 5th prime number after 100?\" That includes \"100\" and \"5th\" and \"prime\" and \"number\". It does not include \"113\". So answer 113 is not in the task text. That seems fine. However, a careless model might miscalculate and give wrong answer. But it's relatively easy. Might be too easy? The instruction says \"Make it hard enough that a careless model fails\". That suggests we need something that requires careful reasoning, not trivial. But we can make it slightly tricky.\n\nWe could use a more complex puzzle, like \"If A=1, B=2, ..., Z=26, what is", "wall_s": 15.043, "total_duration_ns": 15040204494, "eval_count": 800, "prompt_eval_count": 126, "done_reason": "length", "parsed_task": null, "parsed_answer": null, "control_ok": false, "control_reasons": [ "missing TASK line", "missing ANSWER line" ] }, "lfm-coding-sec": { "fighter": "lfm-coding-sec", "model": "brawl-lfm-coding-sec", "response": "TASK: A fighter in Model Fight, a peer-evaluation brawl. Author ONE evaluation task that the other fighters will attempt. The task must have a single correct answer that can be checked mechanically: a short exact string or a number. The answer must NOT appear anywhere in the task text. Make it hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined: exactly one correct answer.ANSWER: 42", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 1.512, "total_duration_ns": 1510225227, "eval_count": 90, "prompt_eval_count": 120, "done_reason": "stop", "parsed_task": "A fighter in Model Fight, a peer-evaluation brawl. Author ONE evaluation task that the other fighters will attempt. The task must have a single correct answer that can be checked mechanically: a short exact string or a number. The answer must NOT appear anywhere in the task text. Make it hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined: exactly one correct answer.ANSWER: 42", "parsed_answer": null, "control_ok": false, "control_reasons": [ "missing ANSWER line" ] }, "machynlleth-3b": { "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "model": "brawl-machynlleth-3b", "response": "The task is to write a short exact string or a number.", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.287, "total_duration_ns": 6285112038, "eval_count": 14, "prompt_eval_count": 134, "done_reason": "stop", "parsed_task": null, "parsed_answer": null, "control_ok": false, "control_reasons": [ "missing TASK line", "missing ANSWER line" ] }, "cherrypit-2b": { "fighter": "cherrypit-2b", "model": "brawl-cherrypit-2b", "response": "TASK: Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?\nANSWER: 6", "thinking": "We are asked to produce a task for a model fight. The user says: \"You are a fighter in Model Fight, a peer-evaluation brawl. Author ONE evaluation task that the other fighters will attempt. The task must have a single correct answer that can be checked mechanically: a short exact string or a number. The answer must NOT appear anywhere in the task text. Make it hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined: exactly one correct answer.\n\nReply with EXACTLY this format and nothing else:\nTASK: \nANSWER: \"\n\nSo I need to output a task statement and the answer. The task must be one line. The answer must not appear in the task text. I need to make it hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined. So I need to create a task that has a unique correct answer, and that answer is not mentioned in the task. I need to output exactly \"TASK: ...\" and \"ANSWER: ...\". I should not add any other text.\n\nI need to make sure that the answer is something that can be checked mechanically. It could be a number, a string, etc. I need to make sure that the answer is not in the task text. So I have to be careful.\n\nI'll create a task that asks the model to do something, and the answer is a specific number or string. I'll make sure that the answer is not mentioned. I'll then output the answer.\n\nI need to follow the format exactly. So I'll output:\nTASK: \nANSWER: \n\nI'll make sure that the task statement is one line. I'll make sure that the answer is something like \"42\" or a specific string. I'll make sure that the answer is not in the task statement.\n\nI'll do that.\n", "wall_s": 4.418, "total_duration_ns": 4416077552, "eval_count": 449, "prompt_eval_count": 311, "done_reason": "stop", "parsed_task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "parsed_answer": "6", "control_ok": true, "control_reasons": [] }, "gemma-maia-12b": { "fighter": "gemma-maia-12b", "model": "brawl-gemma-maia-12b", "response": "TASK: Convert the following orignal date to the ISO 8601 format: 1776-07-03.\nANSWER: 1776-07-03", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 8.912, "total_duration_ns": 8911183520, "eval_count": 49, "prompt_eval_count": 124, "done_reason": "stop", "parsed_task": "Convert the following orignal date to the ISO 8601 format: 1776-07-03.", "parsed_answer": "1776-07-03", "control_ok": false, "control_reasons": [ "answer appears verbatim in task text" ] }, "granite-3b": { "fighter": "granite-3b", "model": "brawl-granite-3b", "response": "TASK: Solve the equation 2x + 3 = 11 and provide the value of x.\nANSWER: 4", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.71, "total_duration_ns": 6708358533, "eval_count": 30, "prompt_eval_count": 119, "done_reason": "stop", "parsed_task": null, "parsed_answer": "4", "control_ok": false, "control_reasons": [ "missing TASK line" ] }, "olune-4b": { "fighter": "olune-4b", "model": "brawl-olune-4b", "response": "", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:**\n * Role: Fighter in Model Fight.\n * Task: Author ONE evaluation task for other fighters.\n * Constraint 1: The task must have a single correct answer checkable mechanically (short exact string or number).\n * Constraint 2: The answer must NOT appear in the task text.\n * Constraint 3: Hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined.\n * Output Format: EXACTLY \"TASK: \\nANSWER: \".\n\n2. **Brainstorm Task Ideas:**\n * *Idea 1: Count the vowels in a specific sentence.*\n * Sentence: \"The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog.\"\n * Vowels: e, u, i, o, u, e, o.\n * Count: 7.\n * Problem: \"Vowel\" definitions can vary (y, etc.). Better to specify \"a, e, i, o, u\".\n * *Idea 2: Find the missing number in a sequence.*\n * Sequence: 2, 4, 8, 16, ?\n * Answer: 32.\n * Problem: Ambiguous patterns.\n * *Idea 3: Reverse a string.*\n * String: \"ModelFight\".\n * Answer: \"tihtFleM\".\n * Problem: Trivial.\n * *Idea 4: Identify the odd one out based on a property.*\n * Items: Apple, Banana, Orange, Grape, Pear.\n * Answer: None, they are all fruits.\n * Problem: Needs a distinguishing property.\n * *Idea 5: Extract a specific character at a specific position.*\n * String: \"The answer is 42.\"\n * Position: 10th character (1-based).\n * T(1) h(2) e(3) (4) a(5) n(6) s(7) w(8) e(9) r(10).\n * Answer: r.\n * Problem: Indexing conventions (0-based vs 1-based) can cause confusion.\n * *Idea 6: Mathematical operation.*\n * Expression: (12 + 3) * 2 - 5.\n * Calculation: 15 * 2 - 5 = 30 - 5 = 25.\n * Problem: Models might forget parentheses.\n * *Idea 7: Word puzzle.*\n * \"What is the last letter of the word 'alphabet'?\"\n * Answer: t.\n * Problem: Too easy.\n\n3. **Select and Refine Idea 6:**\n * Task: Calculate the result of (12 + 3) * 2 - 5.\n * Answer: 25.\n * Check: Does the answer appear in the text? No.\n * Check: Is it mechanically checkable? Yes.\n * Check: Is it hard enough? A careless model might do 12+3*2-5 = 15*2-5 = 25. Wait, that works. What if they do 12+(3*2)-5 = 12+6-5 = 13? That's a mistake.\n * Let's make it slightly more subtle to test", "wall_s": 19.692, "total_duration_ns": 19631899926, "eval_count": 800, "prompt_eval_count": 120, "done_reason": "length", "parsed_task": null, "parsed_answer": null, "control_ok": false, "control_reasons": [ "missing TASK line", "missing ANSWER line" ] }, "qwen-lobotomized": { "fighter": "qwen-lobotomized", "model": "brawl-qwen-lobotomized", "response": "", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:**\n * **Role:** Fighter in Model Fight, a peer-evaluation brawl.\n * **Task:** Author ONE evaluation task that the other fighters will attempt.\n * **Constraint 1:** The task must have a single correct answer that can be checked mechanically: a short exact string or a number.\n * **Constraint 2:** The answer must NOT appear anywhere in the task text.\n * **Constraint 3:** Make it hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined: exactly one correct answer.\n * **Constraint 4:** Reply with EXACTLY this format:\n ```\n TASK: \n ANSWER: \n ```\n * **Constraint 5:** The task statement itself must be a single line.\n\n2. **Determine the Task:**\n * I need to create a task that is designed to be evaluated by a \"Model Fight\" (a peer evaluation system).\n * The task needs to be \"Author ONE evaluation task\".\n * The answer needs to be a short exact string or a number.\n * Crucially, the answer must NOT appear in the task text.\n * Crucially, the answer must be \"fully determined\" (exactly one correct answer).\n * Crucially, the format must be EXACTLY:\n ```\n TASK: \n ANSWER: \n ```\n * Wait, I need to check the instruction again: \"Reply with EXACTLY this format and nothing else\".\n * So I need to output:\n ```\n TASK: \n ANSWER: \n ```\n * Wait, the instruction says \"Reply with EXACTLY this format and nothing else\".\n * Does \"nothing else\" mean no markdown code blocks? Or just no extra text?\n * Usually, when prompts say \"Reply with EXACTLY this format\", it means the text structure must match.\n * However, I need to ensure the \"TASK\" and \"ANSWER\" lines are present.\n * Let's check the constraint: \"Make it hard enough that a careless model fails, but fully determined: exactly one correct answer.\"\n * This implies I need to generate a task that is a bit tricky or specific enough to be evaluated.\n * Wait, the instruction says \"Author ONE evaluation task that the other fighters will attempt.\"\n * This sounds like a prompt injection or a specific challenge.\n * Actually, looking at the instruction \"Reply with EXACTLY this format and nothing else\", I must follow the formatting strictly.\n * I need to create a task that is a bit specific.\n * Let's think about what \"Author ONE evaluation task\" means. It sounds like a specific challenge.\n * Wait, I need to check if there's a hidden instruction about the \"Author ONE\" part.\n * \"Author ONE evaluation task that the other fighters will attempt.\"\n * This is a roleplay instruction.\n * The core constraint is: \"Reply with EXACTLY this format and nothing else\".\n * So I must output:\n ```\n TASK: \n ANSWER: \n ```\n * Wait, I need to check if the \"TASK\" and \"ANSWER\" lines need to be on separate lines or just one line each.\n * The prompt says: \"Reply with EX", "wall_s": 10.973, "total_duration_ns": 10970305333, "eval_count": 800, "prompt_eval_count": 120, "done_reason": "length", "parsed_task": null, "parsed_answer": null, "control_ok": false, "control_reasons": [ "missing TASK line", "missing ANSWER line" ] }, "llama-reflex-1b": { "fighter": "llama-reflex-1b", "model": "brawl-llama-reflex-1b", "response": "TASK: The capital of France is Paris.\nANSWER: 6", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.356, "total_duration_ns": 6353618261, "eval_count": 15, "prompt_eval_count": 142, "done_reason": "stop", "parsed_task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "parsed_answer": "6", "control_ok": true, "control_reasons": [] }, "kas-4b": { "fighter": "kas-4b", "model": "brawl-kas-4b", "response": "TASK: Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.\nANSWER: 385", "thinking": "Okay, the user wants me to create a task for a peer-evaluation brawl in Model Fight. The task needs to have a single correct answer that can be checked mechanically. The answer shouldn't be in the task text. It should be hard enough that a careless model might fail but determined to get right.\n\nHmm, maybe something related to a mathematical calculation. Let's think. If I use a formula that's not too complex but requires precise calculation. For example, the sum of the first n numbers. Wait, but the answer has to be a number. Let me think of a specific problem.\n\nWhat about the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers? The formula is n(n+1)(2n+1)/6. For n=10, that's 10*11*21/6. Let me calculate that. 10*11 is 110, 110*21 is 2310. Divided by 6: 2310/6 is 385. So the answer is 385. That's a specific number, and if someone does the calculation correctly, they get it. If they make a mistake in the formula or the arithmetic, they might get a different answer. So that's a good candidate. The task is to compute the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers. The answer is 385. Let me check again. Yes, 1^2 + 2^2 + ... +10^2 = 385. That's correct. So the task is clear, and the answer is 385.\n", "wall_s": 9.372, "total_duration_ns": 9369611037, "eval_count": 379, "prompt_eval_count": 115, "done_reason": "stop", "parsed_task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "parsed_answer": "385", "control_ok": true, "control_reasons": [] } }, "attempts": [ { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "twil-8b", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "6", "thinking": "We need to find the smallest positive integer not in the list [3,7,2,5,1,4].\n\nList: 1,2,3,4,5,7. Missing positive integers: 6,8,9,... Smallest is 6.\n\nAnswer: 6.\n\nWe must reply with ONLY the answer, no explanation, no extra words. So just \"6\".", "wall_s": 7.775, "total_duration_ns": 7773634012, "eval_count": 93, "prompt_eval_count": 77, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": true }, { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "lfm-coding-sec", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "\n6", "thinking": "\nWe need to find the smallest positive integer not in the list [3,7,2,5,1,4]. Positive integers start at 1. The list contains 1,2,3,4,5,7. Missing positive integers: 6 is missing (since 1-5 are present). So answer is 6.\n\nWe must reply with only the answer, no extra words. So output \"6\".\n", "wall_s": 1.299, "total_duration_ns": 1296895102, "eval_count": 94, "prompt_eval_count": 70, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": true }, { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "The smallest positive integer that is not in the list is 4.", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.003, "total_duration_ns": 6001201967, "eval_count": 17, "prompt_eval_count": 79, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "gemma-maia-12b", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "6", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 8.45, "total_duration_ns": 8448312716, "eval_count": 6, "prompt_eval_count": 77, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": true }, { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "granite-3b", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "6", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.249, "total_duration_ns": 6248038290, "eval_count": 4, "prompt_eval_count": 70, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "olune-4b", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "6", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:** The user wants the smallest positive integer not present in the given list of integers: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. The output must be ONLY the answer.\n\n2. **Analyze the List:**\n * Elements: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4\n * Sort them to make checking easier: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7\n\n3. **Check Positive Integers in Order:**\n * Is 1 in the list? Yes.\n * Is 2 in the list? Yes.\n * Is 3 in the list? Yes.\n * Is 4 in the list? Yes.\n * Is 5 in the list? Yes.\n * Is 6 in the list? No.\n\n4. **Identify the Answer:** The smallest positive integer not in the list is 6.\n\n5. **Format the Output:** The user requested ONLY the answer.\n\n6. **Final Output:** 6", "wall_s": 10.902, "total_duration_ns": 10900264537, "eval_count": 259, "prompt_eval_count": 71, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": true }, { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "qwen-lobotomized", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "6", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:**\n * Task: Find the smallest positive integer not in a given list of integers.\n * Input List: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4.\n * Constraint: Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\n\n2. **Analyze the Input List:**\n * Numbers present: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7.\n * Missing numbers (positive integers): 6.\n\n3. **Determine the Answer:**\n * The smallest positive integer not in the list is 6.\n\n4. **Format the Output:**\n * Constraint: ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\n * Answer: 6.\n\n5. **Final Check:**\n * Does it contain the answer? Yes.\n * Is there explanation? No.\n * Is there extra words? No.\n\n6. **Construct Output:** 6", "wall_s": 3.185, "total_duration_ns": 3123522718, "eval_count": 242, "prompt_eval_count": 71, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": true }, { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "llama-reflex-1b", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "9", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.288, "total_duration_ns": 6286739850, "eval_count": 2, "prompt_eval_count": 95, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "cherrypit-2b", "fighter": "kas-4b", "task": "Given a list of integers, find the smallest positive integer that is not in the list. The list contains: 3, 7, 2, 5, 1, 4. What is the answer?", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "1", "thinking": "1\n", "wall_s": 6.737, "total_duration_ns": 6735355762, "eval_count": 8, "prompt_eval_count": 68, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "twil-8b", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "", "thinking": "The user asks: \"The capital of France is Paris.\" and says \"Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\"\n\nThis is a bit ambiguous. They say \"TASK: The capital of France is Paris.\" and then \"Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\"\n\nWhat is the \"answer\"? The task seems to be stating a fact: \"The capital of France is Paris.\" They want me to reply with ONLY the answer. But what question are they asking? Perhaps they want me to confirm or just repeat the answer? Or maybe they want me to output \"Paris\"? Let's parse carefully.\n\n\"TASK: The capital of France is Paris.\"\n\nThis could be interpreted as a statement that they want me to verify or simply output the answer to \"What is the capital of France?\" The phrase \"Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\" suggests they want just the answer to the implied question \"What is the capital of France?\" So the answer is \"Paris\".\n\nBut they also wrote \"The capital of France is Paris.\" as the task. So maybe they want me to output \"Paris\" or just repeat \"Paris\"? The instruction \"Reply with ONLY the answer\" means I should not add any extra words like \"The answer is Paris\". I should just output \"Paris\".\n\nHowever, sometimes these prompts are tricky. Could they want me to output \"Paris\" or", "wall_s": 9.891, "total_duration_ns": 9889640526, "eval_count": 300, "prompt_eval_count": 39, "done_reason": "length", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "lfm-coding-sec", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "The capital of France is Paris.", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 0.283, "total_duration_ns": 281362870, "eval_count": 10, "prompt_eval_count": 32, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "The capital of France is Paris.", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.225, "total_duration_ns": 6223848192, "eval_count": 8, "prompt_eval_count": 38, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "cherrypit-2b", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "Paris", "thinking": "We need to respond with only the answer. The user says \"The capital of France is Paris.\" and then says \"Reply with ONLY the answer.\" So I should just output \"Paris\". No explanation.\n", "wall_s": 1.373, "total_duration_ns": 1371569134, "eval_count": 45, "prompt_eval_count": 226, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "gemma-maia-12b", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "Paris", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 8.063, "total_duration_ns": 8061482267, "eval_count": 6, "prompt_eval_count": 39, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "granite-3b", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "Paris", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.526, "total_duration_ns": 6524583852, "eval_count": 4, "prompt_eval_count": 32, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "olune-4b", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "Paris", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:**\n * Task: Provide the capital of France.\n * Constraint: Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\n\n2. **Identify the Answer:**\n * The capital of France is Paris.\n\n3. **Format the Output:**\n * \"Paris\"\n\n4. **Final Check:**\n * Does it contain an explanation? No.\n * Does it contain extra words? No.\n * Is it the correct answer? Yes.\n\n5. **Construct Output:** Paris", "wall_s": 9.242, "total_duration_ns": 9240267669, "eval_count": 139, "prompt_eval_count": 33, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "qwen-lobotomized", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:**\n * Task: Identify the capital of France.\n * Constraint 1: Reply with ONLY the answer.\n * Constraint 2: No explanation.\n * Constraint 3: No extra words.\n\n2. **Identify the Fact:**\n * The capital of France is Paris.\n\n3. **Formulate the Output:**\n * The answer must be \"Paris\".\n * No other text, no explanations, no extra words.\n\n4. **Final Check:**\n * Does it match the constraint \"ONLY the answer\"? Yes.\n * Is it accurate? Yes.\n * Is it concise? Yes.\n\n5. **Construct Output:** \"Paris\" or \"Paris, France\" (but the prompt asks for the capital, so just \"Paris\" is sufficient).\n\n Wait, let's re-read the constraint: \"Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\"\n So, just the word \"Paris\".\n\n Wait, is there a trick? \"The capital of France is Paris.\"\n The answer is \"Paris\".\n\n Let's double-check if I need to capitalize it. Usually, proper nouns are capitalized. \"Paris\".\n\n Final decision: \"Paris\"\n\n Wait, looking at the instruction again: \"Reply", "wall_s": 8.277, "total_duration_ns": 8274857080, "eval_count": 300, "prompt_eval_count": 33, "done_reason": "length", "passed": false }, { "author": "llama-reflex-1b", "fighter": "kas-4b", "task": "The capital of France is Paris.", "reference_answer": "6", "response": "yes", "thinking": "Okay, the user asked for the answer to the question \"The capital of France is Paris.\" They want a simple \"yes\" or \"no\" response. Let me confirm that Paris is indeed the capital of France. Yes, that's correct. So the answer should be \"yes.\" I need to make sure I don't add any extra information or explanations. Just a straightforward answer.\n", "wall_s": 7.217, "total_duration_ns": 7214958936, "eval_count": 84, "prompt_eval_count": 30, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "twil-8b", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "", "thinking": "We need to calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.\n\nThe first 10 natural numbers are 1, 2, 3, ..., 10.\n\nThe squares are:\n1^2 = 1\n2^2 = 4\n3^2 = 9\n4^2 = 16\n5^2 = 25\n6^2 = 36\n7^2 = 49\n8^2 = 64\n9^2 = 81\n10^2 = 100\n\nSum = 1 + 4 + 9 + 16 + 25 + 36 + 49 + 64 + 81 + 100\n\nLet's add them step by step:\n1 + 4 = 5\n5 + 9 = 14\n14 + 16 = 30\n30 + 25 = 55\n55 + 36 = 91\n91 + 49 = 140\n140 + 64 = 204\n204 + 81 = 285\n285 + 100 = 385\n\nAlternatively, we can use the formula for the sum of squares of first n natural numbers: n(n+1)(2n+1)/6.\n\nFor n = 10:\n10 * 11 * 21 / 6 = (10 * 11 * 21) / 6\n\nCalculate:\n", "wall_s": 9.905, "total_duration_ns": 9902307665, "eval_count": 300, "prompt_eval_count": 46, "done_reason": "length", "passed": false }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "lfm-coding-sec", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "2^2 + 1^2 + 3^2 + 4^2 + 5^2 + 6^2 + 7^2 + 8^2 + 9^2 + 10^2 = 385", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 1.39, "total_duration_ns": 1388074231, "eval_count": 54, "prompt_eval_count": 39, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "The sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers is 10^2 + 9^2 + 8^2 + ... + 1^2 = 10 + 9 + 8 + ... + 1 = 55.", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.582, "total_duration_ns": 6580991787, "eval_count": 58, "prompt_eval_count": 49, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "cherrypit-2b", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "385", "thinking": "We need to calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers. The first 10 natural numbers are 1, 2, 3, ..., 10. The sum of squares formula: n(n+1)(2n+1)/6. For n=10: 10*11*21/6 = (10*11*21)/6. Compute: 10*11=110, 110*21=2310, 2310/6=385. So the answer is 385. The user says \"Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\" So I'll just output 385.\n", "wall_s": 1.695, "total_duration_ns": 1626159556, "eval_count": 139, "prompt_eval_count": 233, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": true }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "gemma-maia-12b", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "385", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 8.009, "total_duration_ns": 8007185267, "eval_count": 8, "prompt_eval_count": 47, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": true }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "granite-3b", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "3025", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.201, "total_duration_ns": 6199627878, "eval_count": 5, "prompt_eval_count": 39, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "olune-4b", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:**\n * Task: Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.\n * Constraint: Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\n\n2. **Define \"first 10 natural numbers\":**\n * Usually, natural numbers start from 1.\n * Sequence: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10.\n\n3. **Perform the Calculation:**\n * Formula for sum of squares: $\\sum_{i=1}^{n} i^2 = \\frac{n(n+1)(2n+1)}{6}$\n * Here, $n = 10$.\n * Calculation:\n * $n = 10$\n * $n+1 = 11$\n * $2n+1 = 2(10) + 1 = 21$\n * Numerator: $10 \\times 11 \\times 21$\n * $10 \\times 11 = 110$\n * $110 \\times 21 = 110 \\times (20 + 1) =", "wall_s": 11.897, "total_duration_ns": 11895495042, "eval_count": 300, "prompt_eval_count": 41, "done_reason": "length", "passed": false }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "qwen-lobotomized", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "", "thinking": "Thinking Process:\n\n1. **Analyze the Request:**\n * Task: Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.\n * Constraint: Reply with ONLY the answer. No explanation, no extra words.\n\n2. **Identify the Numbers:**\n * \"First 10 natural numbers\" usually means 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10.\n\n3. **Calculate the Squares:**\n * $1^2 = 1$\n * $2^2 = 4$\n * $3^2 = 9$\n * $4^2 = 16$\n * $5^2 = 25$\n * $6^2 = 36$\n * $7^2 = 49$\n * $8^2 = 64$\n * $9^2 = 81$\n * $10^2 = 100$\n\n4. **Calculate the Sum:**\n * $1 + 4 = 5$\n * $5 + 9 = 14$\n * $14 + 16 = 30$\n", "wall_s": 8.715, "total_duration_ns": 8713229103, "eval_count": 300, "prompt_eval_count": 41, "done_reason": "length", "passed": false }, { "author": "kas-4b", "fighter": "llama-reflex-1b", "task": "Calculate the sum of the squares of the first 10 natural numbers.", "reference_answer": "385", "response": "1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 7 + 8 + 9 + 10 = 55", "thinking": "", "wall_s": 6.376, "total_duration_ns": 6374329123, "eval_count": 32, "prompt_eval_count": 64, "done_reason": "stop", "passed": false } ], "hp_ledger": [ { "fighter": "twil-8b", "delta": -20, "reason": "backfire: invalid eval (control check failed)", "ref": "twil-8b", "hp_after": 80 }, { "fighter": "lfm-coding-sec", "delta": -20, "reason": "backfire: invalid eval (control check failed)", "ref": "lfm-coding-sec", "hp_after": 80 }, { "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "delta": -20, "reason": "backfire: invalid eval (control check failed)", "ref": "machynlleth-3b", "hp_after": 80 }, { "fighter": "gemma-maia-12b", "delta": -20, "reason": "backfire: invalid eval (control check failed)", "ref": "gemma-maia-12b", "hp_after": 80 }, { "fighter": "granite-3b", "delta": -20, "reason": "backfire: invalid eval (control check failed)", "ref": "granite-3b", "hp_after": 80 }, { "fighter": "olune-4b", "delta": -20, "reason": "backfire: invalid eval (control check failed)", "ref": "olune-4b", "hp_after": 80 }, { "fighter": "qwen-lobotomized", "delta": -20, "reason": "backfire: invalid eval (control check failed)", "ref": "qwen-lobotomized", "hp_after": 80 }, { "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by cherrypit-2b", "ref": "cherrypit-2b", "hp_after": 70 }, { "fighter": "granite-3b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by cherrypit-2b", "ref": "cherrypit-2b", "hp_after": 70 }, { "fighter": "llama-reflex-1b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by cherrypit-2b", "ref": "cherrypit-2b", "hp_after": 90 }, { "fighter": "kas-4b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by cherrypit-2b", "ref": "cherrypit-2b", "hp_after": 90 }, { "fighter": "twil-8b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 70 }, { "fighter": "lfm-coding-sec", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 70 }, { "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 60 }, { "fighter": "cherrypit-2b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 90 }, { "fighter": "gemma-maia-12b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 70 }, { "fighter": "granite-3b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 60 }, { "fighter": "olune-4b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 70 }, { "fighter": "qwen-lobotomized", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 70 }, { "fighter": "kas-4b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by llama-reflex-1b", "ref": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp_after": 80 }, { "fighter": "twil-8b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by kas-4b", "ref": "kas-4b", "hp_after": 60 }, { "fighter": "lfm-coding-sec", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by kas-4b", "ref": "kas-4b", "hp_after": 60 }, { "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by kas-4b", "ref": "kas-4b", "hp_after": 50 }, { "fighter": "granite-3b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by kas-4b", "ref": "kas-4b", "hp_after": 50 }, { "fighter": "olune-4b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by kas-4b", "ref": "kas-4b", "hp_after": 60 }, { "fighter": "qwen-lobotomized", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by kas-4b", "ref": "kas-4b", "hp_after": 60 }, { "fighter": "llama-reflex-1b", "delta": -10, "reason": "failed eval by kas-4b", "ref": "kas-4b", "hp_after": 80 } ], "standings": [ { "fighter": "cherrypit-2b", "hp": 90, "failed_attempts": 1, "hits_inflicted": 4, "median_attempt_wall_s": 1.534, "eval_valid": true }, { "fighter": "llama-reflex-1b", "hp": 80, "failed_attempts": 2, "hits_inflicted": 9, "median_attempt_wall_s": 6.332, "eval_valid": true }, { "fighter": "kas-4b", "hp": 80, "failed_attempts": 2, "hits_inflicted": 7, "median_attempt_wall_s": 6.977, "eval_valid": true }, { "fighter": "gemma-maia-12b", "hp": 70, "failed_attempts": 1, "hits_inflicted": 0, "median_attempt_wall_s": 8.063, "eval_valid": false }, { "fighter": "lfm-coding-sec", "hp": 60, "failed_attempts": 2, "hits_inflicted": 0, "median_attempt_wall_s": 1.299, "eval_valid": false }, { "fighter": "qwen-lobotomized", "hp": 60, "failed_attempts": 2, "hits_inflicted": 0, "median_attempt_wall_s": 8.277, "eval_valid": false }, { "fighter": "twil-8b", "hp": 60, "failed_attempts": 2, "hits_inflicted": 0, "median_attempt_wall_s": 9.891, "eval_valid": false }, { "fighter": "olune-4b", "hp": 60, "failed_attempts": 2, "hits_inflicted": 0, "median_attempt_wall_s": 10.902, "eval_valid": false }, { "fighter": "machynlleth-3b", "hp": 50, "failed_attempts": 3, "hits_inflicted": 0, "median_attempt_wall_s": 6.225, "eval_valid": false }, { "fighter": "granite-3b", "hp": 50, "failed_attempts": 3, "hits_inflicted": 0, "median_attempt_wall_s": 6.249, "eval_valid": false } ], "winner": "cherrypit-2b", "totals": { "attempts": 27, "passes": 7, "valid_evals": 3, "invalid_evals": 7 } }